Free shipping over $35
new site launch sale - up to 90% OFF no coupon needed
How are your prices so low?
We buy overstock merchandise from large department stores and pass on those discounts to you.
Are all products new?
Yes. Unless otherwise stated, all products are brand new. Some may have retail stickers or show minor signs of shelf wear on the packaging.
We do also have an open-box and used collectibles and used book departments coming soon.
Where are you located?
We're based in New York and nearly all orders ship from there.
If I had to describe this peanut butter with a cliche, it would be "looks can be deceiving." After stirring the peanut butter, it will look, and admittedly is, a bit thin or runny. However, even being a bit thin, it will stick to the roof of your mouth like the thickest of peanut butters. The taste is wonderful as well. It tastes like you've shoved a handful of salted roasted peanut into your mouth. I already made a trip back and bought another pair even though I'm not even done with the first jar!
This is a very runny peanut butter, almost like they added extra oil to it It is very homogenous and the the oil does not separate as it actually pours out of the jar at 72 F degrees. We have to keep it cold in the Fridge in order to spread it like other peanut butters. If they sold a Crunchy version I might try that... otherwise what we have now, well... this will be the last we'll buy... sorry... Oh, at least it wasn't overly salted and has a pleasant peanut taste as it runs out of the sandwiches.
We like shopping at COSTCO and realize that this current COVID issue is causing significant difficulties. However we have been under "Stay In Place"orders for some time needing to order delivery on many food items. We are also not in an area with a near by COSTCO store. We ordered one time and while told it would be a few days longer than normal, we were never sent any shipping information and it showed up more than two weeks from the day we ordered. I called customer service twice during this period and they could give me no information at all on my order, A truly Bad experience when other companies kept us well informed and shipping was virtually on time.
Took me far too long to find a way to provide feedback. This peanut “butter” is delicious but too runny to call it butter. It has always had the viscosity of liquid dish soap. I’ve made peanut butter before, needing a drop of oil to get it to go from powder to liquid, so this seems they add oil to increase volume and weight, sacrificing any texture. Ok for dips and dressings, but not on toast :(
Ok...we really wanted to like this peanut butter. The woman walking by us as we were discussing the peanut butter purchase said "my father loves that peanut butter" so enthusiastically that we said "well, if it's good enough for that random woman's father, then it will be good enough for us!" Not so much. I stirred it....a long time...and put a spoonful in my mouth. Then it took on a life of it's own and began to slowly strangle me. My tongue was stuck to the roof of my mouth and I couldn't get it out of my mouth and into the sink fast enough! Maybe I just need preservatives and sugar in my peanut butter.
